My icons is not in because some biased icon checkers don't like who did my icon, if i asked for the icon to be voted in, it would be, maybe not because of game politics and that kind of ****.

There are/were icons that were totally a recolor and still got in, maybe those icon checkers could stop looking at every detail just to not put it in the game and do a fair "job".

Yeah, claim that i'm harrasing icon checkers with your broken rule that let's you revoke anyone privilege to have an icon, i'd rather not have an icon than one i don't want.


Mod Edit: Image macro containing inappropriate language removed.

_________________________________________

Boberamera wrote:

YOU'RE ALL BIASED

New rules, get used to them brah

_________________________________________

Darlute wrote:

Boberamera wrote:

YOU'RE ALL BIASED

New rules, get used to them brah

I'm sure Gaku won't like that "icon checkers have the right to be biased rule"


@Relleth: Please, don't use my real name. And that was meant to be harassment. It was irony.

_________________________________________

cept if they were biased, they wouldnt have given you detailed instructions on what to fix and examples. your case is really just nothing at this point

_________________________________________

I don't think you quite understand how bias works.

_________________________________________

wrote:

RUEL 14

ps: harassment rule is bs. when has it even been a good idea to make anyone in a position of power immune from being picked on? Harassment regarding icons, sure, but a blanket harassment rule? You should pull your heds out your butts.

_________________________________________

^^^^^^^^^^^^




_________________________________________

HE DOESN'T EXIST?!?!

_________________________________________

I don't see the problem here. Icon rules were revamped to make it HARDER to get icons in. It's no longer a -make icon -send in -get in. Now you have to make an icon and make it WELL and make sure it fits in the game. Gaku's rules were strict once upon a time. And people didn't have problems.

Really all this is is a transference of not liking the icon checkers and using it as an excuse to complain. Just like Blossom's topic about me not knowing how to icon and how I shouldn't be an icon checker. Have you guys noted all the complaints coming from your side?

Maybe you should accept that icon rules are different and work with us. Dean has worked with us by suggesting some changes. Instead you guys just ***** and moan and hope to get icon checkers removed. Now I haven't looked at the similarities of the icon but two icon checkers said they saw it right away, so it's probably something. And Deylin you keep going back to waah others have been added in before. That was before. An obvious recolor or bad edit is in now please tell us I'd like to see it.

Why this game has so much drama over little stuff astounds me. I can not understand it. You guys overdue everything. Try working with us instead of working against us and see how much smoother things go.

And those of you who agree with this decision aren't helping either. This topic has been addressed. There is no longer a need to post. No one is right and everyone is right welcome to the internet.

Is this going to happen every time an icon is denied? Like I said; it's no longer a "make an icon put it in" task. Now you have to actually make a CUSTOM icon. It's a custom icon for a reason, boys and girls.

_________________________________________

Queen Nolynnatrix says
are you being serious
There
I found it myself.
Im sure you can figure out the rest
Lord Cea says
Well
Kati is talking to me about this right now
she knows too apparently
she didn't see it originally
Queen Nolynnatrix says
yeah
-of course not-
Lord Cea says
She's gonna get it removed I think haha
Queen Nolynnatrix says
Good



Point proven.

_________________________________________

If I didn't know about the icon means I didnt vote on the icon. We are now revoting on Shatter's icon. Whatever the outcome will determine your suggested icons as well. Our decision will be posted when it has come to a conclusion.

_________________________________________

Here is the final decision.

Shatter's icon will be removed, however due to our fumble his icon will be fixed by one of us. Reasons are follows: victory, hurt, and wounded all come from FF6 Sabin's icon.

As for the other two icons in questions. You will be in charge of fixing your own icons. If you do not then your icon will not be put in. There will be no compromises.

Mr. Bob's icon: you need to fix the hair, change your death state, and make a victory state.

The other Deylin icon: Your death state needs to be changed. It is FF6 Terra's icon and you need a victory state.



_________________________________________

I'll change them sooner or later. I was going to change them, I just wanted it to be made clear that there were other icons in the games that were rips and I felt like the icon checkers were being biased.

Also - why is a victory state mandatory? Not *****ing, just a question, I don't see why one is needed...

_________________________________________

ChocoBabyCarrot wrote:

I'll change them sooner or later. I was going to change them, I just wanted it to be made clear that there were other icons in the games that were rips and I felt like the icon checkers were being biased.

Also - why is a victory state mandatory? Not *****ing, just a question, I don't see why one is needed...

all of the proper states have to be included with an icon, including "victory". Otherwise the icons won't be accepted

_________________________________________

Victory state is mandatory because of the same reason the walk state is mandatory. How is an icon complete without it?

_________________________________________

Because it is mandatory and it isnt getting in without one.

_________________________________________

A walk state is mandatory because you're constantly walking. Victory states should be optional. Either you want one or you don't.

Edit: Can I see a screen shot of Kyouge's icon/can it be sent to me. I want to investigate -that- icon out too.

_________________________________________

Do you mean all victory states in general or 'unique' ones (rather than the standard lifting-your-arms-in-the-air victory that almost every class icon has)?

_________________________________________

Every time you walk you use the walk state.

Every time you get hurt you use the hurt state.

Every time you die you use the dead state.

Every time you end a battle you use the victory state.

Every time you X you Y.

So if an icon does X you need to have Y to have the icon "complete".

_________________________________________

You're not an icon checker, you don't have a right to investigate anything.

_________________________________________